SRINAGAR, JAMMU AND KASHMIR: The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) has raised fresh questions over political freedoms in Jammu and Kashmir after senior party functionary Raja Shakeel strongly condemned what he described as repeated restrictions on the movement of AAP’s Jammu and Kashmir president and elected legislator, Mehraj Malik.
Shakeel, the party’s spokesperson for the Doda-52 Assembly constituency, accused the authorities of obstructing Malik’s attempts to meet people across the Kashmir Valley, alleging that he had been prevented from visiting Kulgam, Shopian and, most recently, Pulwama.
The allegations have brought renewed attention to a politically sensitive question in Jammu and Kashmir: whether the government’s repeated assertions of improved security and restored normalcy are being accompanied by greater freedom for elected representatives to carry out political activities.
In a strongly worded statement shared with The Chenab Times, Shakeel questioned both the Jammu and Kashmir government and the BJP-led Central Government over the alleged restrictions.
“If the Central Government repeatedly claims that peace and normalcy have been restored in Jammu and Kashmir, then what kind of normalcy is this where a public representative is repeatedly stopped from visiting different districts and meeting the people?” Shakeel asked.
“True peace is reflected through democratic freedom, public participation and the right to express concerns without restrictions,” he added.
Questions over political freedom
For Shakeel, the controversy extends beyond the movement of a single political leader. He argued that the ability of elected representatives to engage with citizens, hear their grievances and raise issues affecting their public is central to the functioning of a democracy.
He said that restricting such interactions risks weakening the relationship between political representatives and the people they are elected to serve.
According to the AAP spokesperson, political outreach should not be viewed as a threat to normalcy, particularly when public representatives seek to engage with public through peaceful and democratic means.
Shakeel maintained that meeting people, listening to their problems and bringing those concerns before the relevant authorities are among the most important responsibilities of political leadership.
His remarks come against a backdrop of continuing debate over the extent of political freedoms in Jammu and Kashmir, where the restoration of an elected government has not ended disagreements over administrative powers, public assembly and the role of security agencies.
The precise circumstances of each reported restriction, including any formal orders or security assessments, remain unclear.
A wider dispute over Malik’s political outreach
The controversy is not the first involving Mehraj Malik‘s attempts to organise political programmes outside his Doda constituency.
In June 2026, Malik accused the administration and police of preventing him from undertaking a planned political tour across Jammu and Kashmir. He alleged that applications for public meetings had been submitted in advance but that permission had either been denied or not formally communicated.
At the time, the AAP also alleged that Malik was stopped while travelling towards the Kashmir Valley, where he intended to address public gatherings and interact with party workers.
The dispute drew criticism from AAP national convenor Arvind Kejriwal, who questioned why an elected representative was reportedly being prevented from meeting people following his release from detention.
More recently, on November 17, local media reported fresh allegations from Malik that authorities were repeatedly denying permission for his public programmes across Kashmir, sometimes communicating decisions shortly before scheduled events. Malik himself also highlighted these restrictions through a livestream on his official Facebook page, where he publicly raised concerns over the repeated obstruction of his political activities and his ability to meet and interact with people across the region.
According to that account, Malik said applications had been submitted approximately 20 days in advance, while subsequent denials were attributed to security concerns.
These reports suggest that the dispute over his political outreach has persisted for several months, although the administrative grounds for each individual decision require separate examination.
From detention to renewed political confrontation
Mehraj Malik, who represents Doda in the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly, emerged as a prominent figure in the region’s politics after becoming AAP’s first elected legislator in the Union Territory in the October 2024 Assembly elections.
His political career has since been marked by confrontations with the administration, including his detention under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act (PSA) in September 2025.
Authorities had invoked the preventive detention law citing concerns related to public order. Malik challenged the detention before the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh.
On April 27, 2026, the High Court quashed the detention order and directed his release, bringing an end to nearly eight months of incarceration under the PSA.
However, his release did not end tensions with the administration.
Malik subsequently alleged that restrictions on his movement and changes to his security arrangements were affecting his ability to perform his political duties.
In September 2026, the High Court directed the authorities to consider his request for restoration of security arrangements and asked the relevant security review committee to assess his threat perception.
The legal proceedings and recurring disputes over public programmes have added another dimension to the debate surrounding the treatment of opposition political representatives in Jammu and Kashmir.
Government claims of normalcy face political scrutiny
Since the revocation of Jammu and Kashmir’s special constitutional status in August 2019, the Central Government has repeatedly presented improvements in security, economic activity and tourism as evidence of progress towards normalcy.
In an official statement issued in June 2026, the Government of India highlighted declining militancy-related incidents, fewer organised shutdowns and increasing development activity as indicators of improved conditions.
The government has consistently maintained that security measures are necessary to protect public order and safeguard residents in a region that continues to face security challenges.
However, political restrictions, including those involving public gatherings and movement, remain contentious.
While India’s Constitution guarantees freedoms of speech, peaceful assembly and movement, these rights are subject to legally permissible restrictions, including those justified by public order and security considerations.
The central question raised by Shakeel’s statement is whether restrictions imposed on political representatives are necessary, proportionate and supported by transparent administrative decisions.
Jammu and Kashmir’s governance structure adds another layer of complexity. Although an elected government headed by Chief Minister Omar Abdullah took office following the 2024 elections, policing and public order remain outside the legislative authority of the Union Territory’s elected assembly and under the Centre’s administrative framework through the Lieutenant Governor.
This division of responsibilities makes accountability for decisions affecting political activities particularly significant.
‘Democracy cannot function by restricting public voices’
Shakeel urged both the Jammu and Kashmir government and the Central Government to uphold democratic principles and ensure that Mehraj Malik is able to travel and interact with people without unjustified interference.
He argued that a government confident about improvements in the region’s security situation should not regard ordinary political engagement as a cause for concern.
“A government confident in its claims of peace and normalcy should have nothing to fear from a leader who wants to listen to the people,” Shakeel said.
“Democracy cannot function by restricting public voices. We will continue to stand for the rights and dignity of the people of Jammu and Kashmir.”
His comments reflect AAP’s broader criticism of what it considers unnecessary administrative interference in the political activities of its state leadership.
At the same time, the specific security and administrative reasons behind the latest reported restrictions have yet to be publicly established through independently verified documentation.
The dispute has raised questions about the distinction between maintaining public order and enabling democratic participation, particularly in a region where political normalcy remains a significant part of the wider public debate.
For Shakeel, the answer lies in allowing elected representatives to maintain direct contact with the people they serve.
While the Shopian Police, in an official communication dated November 16, 2026, addressed to the District Magistrate, cited operational commitments and other assignments as reasons why permission for AAP’s proposed public meeting at Batpora Sports Stadium on November 17 was not feasible, broader questions surrounding the alleged restrictions on Malik’s movement remain unanswered. The letter, which Malik himself shared on social media, provides an official explanation concerning the proposed gathering in Shopian but does not address the wider allegations of repeated obstructions to his political visits across Kashmir. As the controversy continues, questions persist over whether the authorities will provide a comprehensive explanation for these alleged restrictions and clarify how security considerations are being balanced against the democratic rights of elected representatives to travel, engage with the public and conduct peaceful political activities.

The Chenab Times News Desk

